MxMo 10: Festival!

MxMo FestiveIt’s Mixology Monday time again, this month hosted by Brenda at The Spirit World. Brenda chose the theme festive drinks for this iteration. Sounds great to me! Let’s get festive!

Homemade eggnogI chose a drink that I expect a few others will do this time as well: eggnog. And that’s okay, because it seems that just about everybody has a personal favorite recipe for eggnog, so I expect a lot of variation in ingredients and techniques.

And that’s okay, too, because I have a confession. I’m a nogn00b. Oh, I’ve had eggnog before, if you think that stuff you get at the grocery is eggnog. But I can’t recall ever having homemade nog, and this was my first attempt at making it from scratch. I’ll have fun reading what others have done and, I hope, picking up some tips on making a better nog.

(As an aside, there is a great New York State dairy, Ronnybrook Farm, that apparently makes a superb bottled eggnog. Although I’d love to try it at some point, I didn’t want to use their product for this MxMo entry. Where’s the challenge in that?)

So, on to the nog…

I heard from a friend that Alton Brown had done a nog episode for Good Eats, and since Alton has seldom steered me wrong, I decided his would be a good base recipe and a great introduction to eggnogs. One thing I like about Alton Brown is that his recipes are usually a good jumping-off point for experimentation. Once you have the basic flavors and techniques down, you can start to improvise.

I won’t reproduce his recipe here, but I will talk about his technique: He starts by separating four eggs, beating the yolks until they’re light and then adding sugar. He blends a mixture of milk, cream, bourbon, and nutmeg into the yolks. He whips up the whites separately, adds a bit of sugar, and then folds the dairy/yolk mixture into the whites. He chills this for at least an hour before serving.

Now, Alton’s recipe is light on the bourbon–just three ounces for that entire batch. (Brenda, on the other hand, uses twenty-four ounces of liquor in a nog that calls for six eggs. It’s interesting to compare their recipes: Alton’s a freakin’ lightweight.)

After I finished mixing it all up, but before chilling it, I pulled a bit aside for us to taste. Jen and I both loved this recipe, low-octane though it may be. The nog was fresh, creamy, rich, and delicious, with just a hint of bourbon.

A hint of booze, however, is not enough for this drink, so when I served it, I poured a couple ounces of dark rum into a glass, added the nog, and stirred. Next time I make this, I’ll very likely just add more booze from the start.

photograph by Jennifer Hess


7 thoughts on “MxMo 10: Festival!

  1. I have tried the Ronnybrook Egg Nog and it is fan-freaking-tastic. It’s so rich, actually, that you can water it down with milk and it’s still great. (Is that defeating the purpose of The Nog? I am a philistine, perhaps.)

    And speaking of the Food Network, I was running on the treadmill at the gym yesterday and watching Food Network (what can I say; it motivates me) and I happened to catch this week’s episode of From the Can Atrocities with Sandra Lee and she made the three most appalling holiday “cocktails” I have ever seen. One of them was garnished with a candy cane. Another won had a rim dipped in honey and ADORNED WITH COCONUT FLAKES. I have never been so frightened.


  2. Yeah – for a recipe that is supposed to yield 6 – 7 servings, 3 ounces of bourbon doesn’t really seem right. I mean most drinks have at least 1 ounce of some sort of alcohol. In all honestly, though… with kids around for the holidays, I would make the nog “dry,” and add the alcohol for adults individually. 🙂


  3. Sorry it took so long for comments to appear. My sites are blocked by the filtering software at work (sigh), so I can only check comments when I get home (double sigh).

    I think I need to give my wife moderator access here so we can keep the conversation flowing when people have something to say.


  4. Dana, glad to hear the Ronnybrook is good. We love their creamline milk, cream, and ice cream, so I’m not surprised to hear their nog is yummy. We’ll have to get some from Whole Foods or Fresh Direct. As an aside, and speaking of good dairy, have you been to Saxelby’s Cheese in Essex Market? Yummy cheese, and Anne the owner is a total sweetheart.

    Merry: One reason to put the booze into the nog is that it helps mature the eggs and kill any yuck. It also becomes part of the mix as the flavors meld in the fridge. Instead of doing just a Shirley Temple version, I’d instead make two pitchers–one for the adults and one for the kids. Just make sure you mark them well. As an aside, we miss you guys.


  5. Wow, whoever steered you towards the Good Eats eggnog must be super awesome.

    I made a batch myself, but was too impatient to chill the nog sufficiently before consumption. Given the size of the glasses we used, we only got 3 servings out of the batch, so 3 ounces of bourbon seemed to be about right. I used regular-ole Maker’s Mark for mine. I could go higher octane but I don’t think I d want to go too far if I continue to serve it up in pint mugs.


  6. I used to nog every year, and that’s pretty much the recipe I followed, though my spices were different. The balance between cream and whites is key. Also I liked rum instead of bourbon for mine back then, as I was a weird little kid.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s